This book is so good so far! There is a lot of description sometimes that is good to read. Other times I wish Natalie Babbitt would just get on with it. The suspense is getting to me. Should she tell everyone the secret? I hope not. I think that there is great value as in letting life happen. I wouldn’t want Winnie’s grandma to drink the water. I wouldn’t want Winnie to drink it being 10 years old. There’s so much for her to experience in life. I agree 100% with Tuck. I think that I would be bored being the same for 104 years. What would be the point of it all. There would never be any challenges. Don’t drink the water from the spring! DON’T DO IT!
I think that the grandma wouldn’t drink the water,and I like your reading respond because I like how you express your self.
Grandma maybe too old. She may not want to live forever with her aches and pains. I know I wouldn’t want to live with too much pain forever. I agree with Tuck. He is wise.
I think the grandma should drink the water I agree with you Ms.Ucles .
Why do you agree?
I wish the author would be a little less discriptive.
It is necessary in some parts, but in others she could pipe it down. I agree!
Because the girl needs her real family. Not Jesse he is not real family yet.
I agree. She needs to keep the secret and not ruin everyone’s lives with the water.
I really enjoy your replies to my blog post. Please feel free to comment all day long!
Can you please follow me I just started and you seem really cool 🙂 (_BP)
😛